Kurt Cobain / Montage of Heck: The Home Recordings / Deluxe Editions

Scrap the puzzle and add a couple of doc martens for me instead.

Where’s the 2CD Deluxe edition on Amazon US? They only list the single CD & Super Deluxe editions.

Kurt Cobain (March 1992 Flipside Interview): When embarrassing things come out, like stuff I’ve done in my basement on a 2-track or a boombox that are basically just unwritten songs or pieces of songs…when those come out it’s really embarrassing and it frustrates me.

Oh give me a break! These recordings are the type of recordings that artists never want released because they are demo or even below demo quality. Some of the tracks on Lights Out box were terrible. Im amazed Dave and Chris allowed for them to be released (maybe they didnt have a choice with Courtney Love’s greedy claws already out). Wish they’d stop this barrel scraping.

I traded and collected Nirvana-bootlegs already in the 90’s, so Im kinda still interested to hear whats left in the vaults, besides the new edition of Kurt’s private demo-version of Sappy is revelation compared to what has been circulating bootlegs since the 90’s. The bootlegged versions had some serious problems with quality and too much hiss, but this editions sounds just excellent. And that cover from The Beatles that he recorded, “And I Love Her” sounds so eerie and morose with hint of R.E.M.-influences, nice to hear it finally.

I think, that with the wonderful documentary of Montage Of Heck, they surely will try to release and do little cashing on these once again, but I think that all the postcards, jigsaw and stuff are really over the top. Even Kurt would not have liked to see this kind of super deluxe release, some of the stuff was private already in the start and was not meant to be for the average Joe to hear these anyways.

I think that I might stream this first and then maybe buy digital download-edition or evene some physical-edition if I really feel like it.
Im going to do justice for Kurt and only cherish those releases that he accepted.
As much as I like anything released from the vaults (by other bands aswell) I might not really feel like spending that much money on these kind of super deluxe-versions since in the long run I might not like the release that much to justify the price-tag.
Maybe the days of these oversized boxsets are really coming to certain end soon? How soon is now?

All the extra crap is just a massive waste of time. No one will bother doing the jigsaw, posting the postcards, using the bookmark or Blu-tacking the poster to their bedroom wall. Put it in a smaller box (triple gatefold digipak for the CD edition) and lower the price. I’d be interested to hear if anyone actually welcomes this extra junk in box sets.

If you are a Nirvana fan, you want to hear what’s left. If not, then you will never understand why that is.

Put me on the list of people that want to hear what is left of both Nirvana and Kurt’s archives. Do Re Mi with Kurt on drums and vocals and other home recordings like Talk to Me and Opinion. Studio material from the final studio session and rehearsals or soundchecks of unreleased songs. Alternate takes from studio sessions. If you consider this a solo album instead of a companion piece to the film maker’s visual work, you are missing the point as much as they are bypassing the barrel completely.

Balloons (Queen) and now puzzles… Anything to make these box sets more expensive…
Speaking of super deluxe box sets, Paul have you heard anything about Roger Waters the wall box set?

Thanks.

For anyone who hasn’t heard Kurt’s home recordings that have been widely available for years on various bootlegs, this release is really nothing to be excited about. Most of the stuff on here aren’t even demos. They are just someone p***ing around with a tape recorder.

This is not scraping the barrel but digging into the ground underneath the barrel. Ridiculous….

Always wanted me one of them Kurt Cobain bookmarks

A whole slew of some fairly, some very interesting high quality Nirvana demos n session tracks have leaked lately – seemingly rejects from the Lights Out box set. They deserve official treatment more than these lo-fi scraps

This seems to be a little ghoulish and I severely doubt some of it was ever meant for the public to hear.

The scraping of the proverbial barrel…which occasionally does bear fruit in terms of ‘furthering our understanding’ of an artist, but rarely….

Those Seattle grunge types and their jigsaw puzzles, eh?

The formatting is very complex.

It doesn’t appear the Super Deluxe is getting a release outside of North America – probably because the ROTW already has a version of the DVD/blu. This may be a relief because many fans will have already bought the book too.

Then, it’s disappointing that the Deluxe appears to be squeezed onto one disc (despite what the press release says), especially when it appears there is music from the film that hasn’t made the jump.

So the Super Deluxe: 1 CD, a Blu-ray (a version of which has already been released), a DVD (redundant for those who have a Blu-ray), a book (which has already been published) and a smattering of ‘collectibles’. Current price – well over $100.

Having seen Montage of the Heck, I’m not convinced. Il like lo-fi but I will stick with my Daniel Johnston collection.